The Liquidity Challenge in Private Credit and its Financial Impact

  • Private credit offers higher returns through the illiquidity premium, although it carries exit risks in times of stress.
  • There is a critical interconnection between direct lending funds and the banking system through liquidity lines.
  • Semi-liquid vehicles and BDCs act as market thermometers, reflecting volatility before the underlying assets.
  • Diversification and the use of contractual guarantees are key tools for mitigating risk in high interest rate environments.

Private credit liquidity

You've probably heard lately that private lending has become fashionable. And with good reason: in the last decade it has grown exponentially, even outpacing the growth of asset management in general. This tool, which essentially involves lending money to companies outside the stock exchange, has become an attractive haven for those seeking higher returns than in traditional markets, although this comes at a price that isn't always immediately apparent.

The crux of the matter is that, since these assets aren't traded on any exchange, they can't be sold instantly. This lack of agility is what we call inherent illiquidity . While on the stock exchange you can exit a position with the push of a button, here it's a different story. This difficulty in recovering your money is precisely what justifies the investor receiving extra returns, but when things get tough in the market, that same characteristic can become a real headache.

private credit crisis
Related article:
A snapshot of the private credit crisis and the risks of the non-bank market

What exactly is private credit and why has it exploded?

To put it simply, private credit is direct financing. Instead of a company issuing a bond that a thousand people buy on the public market, a fund or group of investors agrees to a bilateral loan. This allows the terms to be precisely tailored to the company's needs, but it means the investor accepts that there will be no observable daily price and that the asset is illiquid.

If we ask ourselves why it has grown so much, the answer lies in the 2008 crisis. After that collapse, banks became much stricter and more cautious due to new solvency regulations, leaving a gap in corporate financing. This is where the so-called NBFIs (Non-Bank Financial Intermediaries) came in , taking advantage of the situation to gain ground, especially in risky sectors like technology or in projects that were in very early stages.

Furthermore, the rise of private equity has driven the need for this type of debt to finance operations. Investment giants like Blackstone, Apollo, and KKR have gone from treating this as a secondary concern to making it a fundamental strategic focus of their businesses, scaling operations to unprecedented levels.

BlackRock limits redemptions in one of its private credit funds
Related article:
BlackRock restricts redemptions in a key private credit fund

The enigma of liquidity and the yield premium

When someone invests in private debt, they do so seeking the so-called illiquidity premium . This is an additional percentage return that compensates the investor not only for the risk of default but also for the fact that their money will be tied up for a period of time. Depending on the sector, this premium can range from 2% to 4% above comparable public markets.

However, in turbulent times, investors begin to value liquidity far more than that extra percentage. The problem arises with semi-liquid vehicles or "evergreen" funds . These funds promise regular redemption windows so investors can exit, but the underlying asset remains a long-term loan. It's like trying to draw water from a dry well: if too many people withdraw their money at once, the fund runs out of cash.

A clear example of this was what happened with some Blue Owl funds, where redemption requests exceeded the fund's absorption capacity. To resolve this, the asset manager had to resort to selling assets at face value or changing the rules of the game, making repayments conditional on the actual sale of the loans, thus transforming a promise of liquidity into a reality subordinated to the portfolio.

BDCs: The bridge between the private and the public

Business Development Companies (BDCs) are a very interesting element in this ecosystem. Essentially, they are vehicles that lend money to companies (private credit) but are also publicly traded. This creates a very useful bridge for retail investors to access this world, but it also generates a distortion: the BDC's stock price tends to move much faster than the real value of the loans it holds.

Recently, we've seen BDCs trading at a discount to their net asset value (NAV). This doesn't necessarily mean the companies they lent money to are bankrupt, but rather reflects investor nervousness and psychology . BDCs act as a thermometer; when the market panics, the price drops immediately, even if the loan's fundamentals remain stable.

Megatrends: Long-term Investment Opportunities
Related article:
Megatrends: major long-term investment opportunities

Systemic risk and the shadow of banking

There is a misconception that private lending has removed risk from the banking system. The reality is that risk has not disappeared, but rather been reconfigured. Many of these direct lending funds borrow from banks themselves to improve their return on equity (ROE). If the loans in their portfolios begin to default severely, the risk of contagion to the banking sector is obvious, since banks are the ultimate providers of liquidity.

This interconnectedness becomes dangerous during periods of stress. If funds experience a shock, they massively draw on their bank credit lines, transmitting the problem to the traditional financial system. This is not a risk of immediate default, but rather a simultaneous activation of liquidity at a time when everyone is risk-averse.

Focus areas of surveillance: Software and Artificial Intelligence

If there's one sector keeping analysts up at night, it's software. For years, it was the crown jewel thanks to its recurring revenue and high margins. But the arrival of AI has cast doubt on whether some of those business models will remain viable. This has led to a market that is less selective and penalizes the entire sector equally, relying more on sentiment than on actual performance.

To combat this, the most experienced investors are applying three key strategies:

  • Strengthen the guarantees: Requiring companies to maintain minimum levels of liquidity or limit their debt without permission.
  • Floor clauses: Since these loans are usually variable-rate, minimum amounts are agreed upon to protect against fluctuations. European Central Bank interest rates They go down too much.
  • Real diversification: Don't limit yourself to software, but look for debt backed by commercial real estate assets or infrastructure, which tend to be less correlated.
Private companies and GDP
Related article:
The impact of private companies on the Spanish economy and GDP

Private Credit versus Syndicated Loans (BSL)

It is a common mistake to confuse private credit with widely distributed syndicated loans (BSLs). Although both finance companies with debt, they operate in opposite ways in terms of valuation. With syndicated loans, there is continuous price discovery ; if a company performs poorly, the bond price gradually falls day by day, allowing investors time to react.

In private lending, valuation is periodic and usually depends on the manager. This means that sometimes a loss goes unnoticed for months, and suddenly the asset's value can plummet from 100 to 0 in a single quarter. It's not that private lending is necessarily riskier, but rather that its pricing is less transparent.

On the other hand, there are CLOs (Collateralized Loan Obligations), which are very different structures. CLOs are based on syndicated loans and have a long-term liability structure. This means that the investor's liquidity does not depend on selling the underlying loans, but rather on selling the CLO bond in a highly efficient secondary market, thus avoiding the forced sales that semi-liquid private credit funds experience.


Add as preferred source in Google